One of my favorite parts of Thanksgiving is the traditional line up of different pies at my family gathering. I also love putting my pie making skills to use and making a pie to contribute to the pie line! Diet restrictions can make it tricky and sometimes limit the types of pies you can have during the holidays. Thankfully though, I have been able to find and create many different pies including dairy-free pies, grain-free pies, nut free pies, and gluten free pies. You should be able to find a pie you will enjoy in this Thanksgiving pie recipe roundup!
This post may contain affiliate links. See our Disclosure for more information.
A couple years ago I started working on a personal goal of mine, which was to make every kind of pie that I could think of, with one twist. The pies had to be gluten-free, nut free, corn free, low in sugar, and/or grain-free. I have been having a blast trying new pie recipes and taste testing the results. Some of the new pies I have made are on the ‘make again list’ and other recipes didn’t quite make the list. I am still working on my goal and so far I have made 50 different pies and have 5 more on my ‘to try’ list!
Thanksgiving Pie Recipe Roundup List
Having made that many pies I figured it was about time I put together a list of the different recipes I have used. While trying all the different kinds of pies I have definitely had to make some adaptations to the recipes to fit my dietary needs. It has been fun turning different pie recipes into something that I can eat. So here is the list, you should be able to find at least one pie that you want to make for your Thanksgiving!
Vegetable Pies
Grain-free Pumpkin Pie– gluten-free, nut free, corn free, and dairy-free. This classic pie is one that I make every fall!
Grain-free Sweet Potato Pie– corn free, gluten free, and nut free. Trust me, sweet potato pie will rival pumpkin pie any day! It has the creamy texture of pumpkin pie with a sweet taste!
Gluten-free Zucchini Pie– I adapted this zucchini pie recipe to make it grain-free and dairy free. Just substitute tapioca flour for the all-purpose flour and coconut milk for the milk. I also baked my zucchini in the oven instead of boiling it over the stove top. This pie was surprisingly delicious and I encourage you to give it a try!
Fruit Pies
Grain-free Peach Pie– gluten-free, nut free, and corn free. When I first had peach pie, I knew I was hooked, definitely a must-make fruit pie!
Grain-free Apple Pie– gluten-free, nut free, and corn free. A traditional American pie, this healthy apple pie will definitely remind you of Thanksgiving!
Paleo Strawberry Pie– grain-free, gluten-free, nut free, corn free, and dairy free. I love this strawberry pie! It’s nice that it is a no-bake pie recipe that is sweet and delicious!
Grain-free Blueberry Pie– gluten-free, nut free, and corn free. I don’t make blueberry pie very often, but when I do make it, it reminds me how much I enjoy eating it!
Grain-free Raspberry Pie– gluten-free, corn free, and dairy free. I just used the raspberry filling from this recipe and put it in my own crust.
Gluten-free Pear Pie- gluten-free, grain free, nut free, and corn free. Pear pie surprised me, and now my family is hooked on it!
Grain-free Triple Berry Pie- gluten-free, grain-free, corn free, tree nut free, and dairy free. I used blueberries, strawberries, and raspberries for my three berries, but you can use any combination that you want!
Gluten-free Cherry Pie- gluten-free, nut free, dairy-free, and corn free. Cherry pie is a fun fruit pie to make that is bursting with sweetness. I love the crumb topping!
Pudding Pies
Dairy-free Chocolate Pudding Pie– gluten-free, grain-free, nut free, and corn free. This pudding pie is a staple in my house. It is a super easy pudding recipe to make that sets up perfectly every time.
Grain-free Butterscotch Pie- gluten-free, grain-free, corn free, and tree nut free. This is my dad’s favorite pie, and one of my favorite pies too!
Dairy-free Vanilla Pie– gluten-free, grain-free, dairy free, and tree nut free. Since this pie contains coconut sugar as its sweetener, the filling looks brown instead of cream colored, like you might expect a vanilla pie to be like.
Chocolate & Peanut Butter Pies
Grain-free Fudge Pie- gluten-free, grain-free, nut free, and corn free. This pie is like eating brownies in a pie crust and is one of my favorite pies to bring to family gatherings!
Gluten-free Brownie Pie- gluten-free, grain-free, and nut free. Anna loves this pie! It is different than the fudge pie and tastes delicious served with ice cream.
Chocolate Lover’s Cheesecake Pie- gluten-free, grain-free, and tree nut free. You can make this cheesecake pie dairy-free by using Daiya cream cheese spread, which is dairy free and nut free!
No-Bake Peanut Butter Pie- grain-free, gluten-free, dairy free, and tree nut free. This peanut butter pie is a traditional holiday pie in my family, it’s one that the whole family loves.
Gluten-free Mississippi Mud Pie- gluten-free, grain-free, and nut free. I enjoy making this layered pie and all the different layers blend together perfectly into a delicious pie filling!
Dairy-free Ice Cream Brownie Pie– dairy-free, gluten-free, tree nut free, and grain-free. This pie is my go-to dairy-free pie for when I need to bring a dairy-free dessert to a family gathering.
Decadent Pies
Dairy-free Egg Custard Pie- dairy free, gluten-free, grain-free, and nut free. Egg custard pie is so sweet and delicious, perfect for using up extra eggs!
Dairy-free Maple Syrup Pie- grain-free, gluten-free, dairy free, egg free, tree nut free, corn free, and naturally sweetened. This pie is like taking a spoon full of maple cream, which is absolutely amazing!
Paleo Key Lime Pie– grain-free, dairy free, corn free, and gluten free. Again, I just used the key lime filling from this recipe and put it in my own crust that I made with shredded coconut.
Grain-free Coconut Cream Pie– grain-free, dairy-free, corn free, and gluten-free. I also used just the pie filling from this recipe, but the crust recipe looks good too and it is also grain-free!
Gluten-free S’more Pie- gluten-free, dairy free, nut free, and made from scratch. S’more pie is a super fun pie to make from scratch and it tastes delicious!
So there you have it, a list of many different delicious pie recipes to choose from! All of them are gluten and corn free. Most of them are grain-free and nut free. Some are even dairy free! Hopefully there is enough variety here to provide everyone with a new pie to try! Have fun choosing from this Thanksgiving pie recipe round up list. I would love to hear which pie you choose!
Also, make sure you check out my two Grain-free Pie Crust Recipes to match with your pie of choice!
by Alexa
Liz
November 14, 2017 2:00 pmWow great list! I’m looking for a new way to make a soy free, dairy free, and gluten free pie for Thanksgiving this year. I will be checking these out. Thanks for sharing.
Happy Thanksgiving!
Liz
ThePioneerChicks
November 18, 2017 2:05 pmYour welcome! Happy Thanksgiving to you too!